OH GOD OH GOD MUST WATCH
EDIT: His arguments are the same problem I have with all JRPGs, I just liked the gameplay enough in this enough to tolerate the uninteractive story (plus I read books so I don't mind it being uninteractive). That, and the story hooked me (not Neku's story. The characters were shallow and I didn't give a fuck about them the whole time: I just liked the idea of the Reaper's game and liked to discover more about it).
No random encounters: This usually kills a game for me. It's obnoxious and unfun, and slows play to a crawl. I usually carry around a MILLION repels in Pokemon.
Not turn based: Pokemon being an exception for some reason (I have no idea why), but generally watching the characters line up and jostle around fighting turn by turn is slow and boring and clunky.
This had me laughing pretty hard.